Red Carpet Rewind: Selena Gomez? So Good! Emma Stone? Stunning! Elle? Yell-No!

Emma Stone dazzles in black, Selena Gomez sparkles in cute jeans and heels and Zooey Deschanel owns that red dress and matching lipstick...but what in the heck is supermodel Elle MacPherson wearing?!

Check it all out in this week's Red Carpet Rewind video above!

Who do you think rocked the red carpet? Let us know!