Kim's dress definitely showed a lot more cleavage than Jennifer's, but there is no denying that they both looked incredible.
We have to give Kim a lot of credit as she already has her pre-baby body back just four months after giving birth to daughter North West.
Jennifer, on the other hand, worked hard to shed over 80 pounds, managed to keep the weight off and is looking better than ever these days.
In the clip above, the Fashion Police review the way each of the sexy starlets wore the dress and hand down the decision of who their viewers thought wore this dress best, but we want to know what you think.
Check out the video above and tell us if you agree or disagree with their decision.