The couple was on Teen Mom and made the heart-wrenching decision to give their daughter Carly up for adoption and has struggled with it ever since. They both even got tattoos of their daughter's name and birthday and as one might imagine, she is on their minds a lot.
"I would've felt guilty if I got pregnant again when Carly was 1 or 2. But we've both been yearning for this," she revealed to In Touch. "We're ready to have a baby!"
While there was a huge outpouring of support, there were those who criticized Catelynn and Tyler about their decision. Some argued that it wasn't fair to Carly and others attacked the fact that they're not yet married.
After it went on for a little while, Catelynn finally took to Twitter to defend the statements she made and their decision to try for another baby. "Yes people the intouch interview that's out now is true and those are ALL my own words!#sorrynotsorry," she wrote.
Then, over the weekend, Catelynn's family posted some status updates that really got people talking.
First, her brother posted this update:
Then, her mom posted this one...and Catelynn and Tyler both "liked" it.
It is worth noting that while we have no reason to believe they are fake, none of these accounts have actually been confirmed and Catelynn and Tyler are yet to comment on the pregnancy rumors on any of their verified social media accounts.
Do you guys think Catelynn is really pregnant again?
**UPDATE: Catelynn's mom has just confirmed to Us Weekly that the Teen Mom star is pregnant again**