Kelly finally provided the answer to one of life's great mysteries during an appearance on Watch What Happens Live. When host Andy Cohen asked her to set the record straight during his 'Plead the Fifth' segment, Kelly wasn't shy about sharing.
"We didn't date during Idol, which everybody thought we were dating," she began. "We DID date during - I feel like we weren't dating during the movie - but we did date a little bit. I think any two people who are thrown together that much would date."
:::Sigh::: Things we wish we would have known ten years ago.
Kelly also shared her thoughts on Lady Gaga's Sound of Music tribute and whether or not she was really talking about Miley Cyrus when she tweeted about #PitchyStrippers in reference to some VMA performances.
Check out the video below to hear what she said.