This time, Kendall was ready to take the plunge and get something a little bigger, yet still equally discreet.
Hailey apparently posted the pic below on Snapchat before promptly deleting it.
Both girls both got broken hearts on the inside of their fingers and while Hailey opted for bright red ink, Kendall chose white ink once again. As for why they picked such a sad symbol, a source tells E! News that "they always wanted to get this."
Of course, Kendall's heart is hardly broken right now. The reality star recently started dating Nick Jonas, although they are reportedly taking things very slow and keeping everything very private. "When they're ready and it turns official, we'll start seeing photos," a source told Us Weekly.
Hopefully the only broken heart Kendall will ever have is the one on her finger.