As it turns out, Niall totally called out Liam for the choice, saying he can't be that big of a fan because he only knows two of their songs!
During the BBC Radio 1 Christmas takeover, Niall was told about his band mate's choice and he seemed surprised, saying: "Liam chose The Eagles [as all time favorite band]? That is the most random thing I've ever heard. It's like he made it up on the spot. I'd say he knows two Eagles songs - Hotel California and Desperado, like everyone else...I can't believe that."
Niall calling out Liam for being a fake fan of the Eagles pic.twitter.com/tlZnRIUXdy— 1D Updates! (@1dxxupdatess) December 25, 2015